India Has Coal to Sell and a Future to Build

Anthropic's $1.5 trillion valuation puts India's corporate ambitions in perspective, from technology-led businesses to the capital needed to build global contenders.

Article related image
iStock.com
Author
By Krishnadevan V

Krishnadevan is Editorial Director at BasisPoint Insight. He has worked in the equity markets, and been a journalist at ET, AFX News, Reuters TV and Cogencis.

November 19, 2026 at 9:57 AM IST

On a day when media reports were discussing Anthropic, the company behind Claude, and its $1.5 trillion valuation, Mahanadi Coalfields had a full-page advertisement for its IPO in The Economic Times. One was a reminder of the extraordinary prices investors are willing to pay for artificial intelligence. The other invited them to buy into a company selling coal.

Before the contrast becomes a label for the whole economy, a little caution is advisable, because a newspaper advertisement is not an industrial census and an IPO price is a statement of expectations, not a verdict.

Still, the valuation poses a question worth pursuing. Uday Kotak, who built a financial empire from a small bill-discounting firm, compared it with the combined market capitalisation of India's ten largest listed companies and asked on X whether India is undervalued or needs to catch up with the new world.

Those are different questions. Undervaluation concerns the price investors put on businesses that already exist, while catching up concerns the businesses that might exist next, and it is on the second that India's newer companies will push back.

Beyond Coal

Jio Platforms, Eternal, Swiggy and Urban Company are entitled to object, because India has not been sitting on coal while the world went digital. Jio makes the idea that India stood still hard to sustain, since its disclosures describe a business built on pan-India connectivity and proprietary technology. Eternal spans food delivery, quick commerce, restaurant supplies and going-out services, and none of these is an old asset wearing a new logo.

Add Swiggy and Urban Company, and the story of America inventing while India sells off gets harder to tell.

Delivering dinner on time, or handyman services reliably, is harder than it sounds, and making either business consistently profitable is harder still. These businesses demonstrate an ability to apply technology to large, fragmented markets, but the harder test is whether their operating models can work beyond India.

Global Reach

There is nothing second rate about serving Indian customers, and a business does not become more useful merely because its invoices are denominated in dollars. But domestic scale and global competitiveness are different achievements, and the question is whether a company has built something customers elsewhere would choose and can serve them profitably.

An AI model is only one possible answer, because a product, process, software platform or distinctive service can make the same claim. The test is not whether it looks futuristic in a presentation but why a customer would pay for it rather than pick an alternative.

So, the questions to pose could be what does the business own that rivals cannot easily copy, how much of its advantage depends on local conditions, and what would it take to carry that advantage across a border?

Consumer platforms deserve the same scrutiny as technology developers, without the sneer or the special exemption. Reaching further also costs money, and someone has to fund the journey before the customers arrive.

Money Trail

That is where the two IPOs become more than a newspaper contrast, because beyond their valuations they differ in where the money goes. Anthropic's offering is predominantly newly issued shares, so the money largely goes into the company, whereas Mahanadi Coalfields' reported offering is entirely an offer for sale by Coal India, so it goes to the seller.

That does not make an offer for sale a sign of corporate exhaustion, and fresh shares do not guarantee the proceeds will be spent wisely. But buying an existing business from its owner and financing a company's expansion are different uses of investors' money.

Asking for a trillion-dollar Indian business is easy once someone else has supplied the benchmark, but the harder questions come earlier. Who places the first substantial order, and who keeps backing a product before demand is proven? Answering those takes evidence from real companies and real decisions, because without it "we need more innovation" is a slogan with a budget of zero.

Kotak's provocation is valuable because it makes complacency uncomfortable, but its most productive answer is not a higher multiple for the same set of companies.

The right response to Anthropic is not to ask why investors will not pay more for what India already has. It is to ask what else India can build.