After years of achievement gaps, India may finally meet its disinvestment revenue target in the current financial year ending March 2027 as the government offloads stakes in central public sector enterprises (CPSEs). Yet, the larger question on the direction of the overall privatisation reform announced by the government in its 2020 Atmanirbhar Bharat policy package remains unaddressed.
The New Public Sector Enterprise (PSE) Policy for Atmanirbhar Bharat, brought out in February 2021, classified industry sectors as strategic and non-strategic. For the strategic sectors, including energy, transport and financial services, it was stressed that a ‘bare minimum’ CPSE presence would be maintained. For the remaining strategic PSE, and PSE in non-strategic sectors, privatisation or closures were envisaged. This signified the right path in India’s economic reform journey, strengthening market forces and reducing the government’s ‘wasteful’ administrative expenditure.
Five years later, much of the intent has not translated into reality. The government’s exit from Air India in 2022 raised hopes that the privatisation reform would motivate faster offloading of the government’s corporate stakes. However, over the years, the revenues remained woefully short of lofty budgeted figures, and after the 2023-24 budget experience of the ₹650 billion target yielding a paltry ₹136.27 billion, the expected disinvestment proceeds were clubbed under ‘miscellaneous capital receipts’ in Budget 2024-25. This umbrella head covers both disinvestment and asset monetisation revenues, and perhaps some other capital receipts as well, so that disinvestment targets are now not clearly laid out.
Further, the number of central PSEs increased from 389 in 2021-22 to 475 as of 2024-25, as per the latest PSE Survey. The share of operating CPSEs has declined slightly, with 183 of 291 operating CPSEs garnering gross revenues of less than ₹10 billion. The number of CPSEs identified for closure has, however, increased from 46 in 2021-22 to 75 in 2024-25. The government’s dividend income from operating CPSEs stood at ₹1.39 trillion, even while it stepped up its equity and loans to these enterprises.
This year, receipts from sales of Life Insurance Corporation (LIC) holdings and strategic sale of IDBI Bank are expected to generate most of the budgeted revenue under the head of miscellaneous capital receipts. However, the large proportion of disinvestment cases since the 2021 policy derived revenues from Offers for Sale (OFS), rather than full privatisation and exits. Through the quick OFS route, most of the stakes offered in the market comprise far less than 10% of the government’s holdings in the PSE. The Department of Investment and Public Asset Management (DIPAM) data shows few outright strategic disinvestments after the Air India sale, with proceeds of barely ₹1.2 billion.
PSE privatisation or even disinvestment has never been easy in India. Given the entrenched nature of PSEs, challenges relate to complex legal and regulatory processes, concerns about employment, and political resistance. For example, IDBI Bank’s strategic restructuring involved an approval by the Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs, and then a two-stage bidding process monitored by the Inter-Ministerial Group, the Core Group of Secretaries on Disinvestment, and the Alternative Mechanism comprising an empowered group of Cabinet Ministers. From its initiation to the final approval to the strategic buyer, the process took more than five years.
With the spurt in disinvestment in the current financial year, it is possible that some of the first few teething issues in the lengthy and convoluted process may have become streamlined.
However, as earlier committed by the government, the larger goal should remain complete exit from PSEs, in place of small and piecemeal OFS that hardly dilute its equity holdings. The Atmanirbhar Bharat strategy announced in 2020 was clear that industry should have minimal presence of the government, and this laudable objective should be adhered to. Happily, disinvestment now appears to enjoy a larger buy-in from the political class and the public, as long as the process is perceived as being transparent and fair.
The disinvestment process also needs to be fast-tracked and made less complex. Lengthy processes tend to discourage serious bidders and raise costs, while adding to uncertainty in equity markets. With 75 CPSEs slated for closure, the internal preparations for privatisation or sale of assets must make faster progress. A key issue that often arises in these cases is filing of petitions in courts which take a long time to resolve. Time-bound judicial processes and quick resolutions would help in disinvestment.
Privatisation of CPSEs – and eventually state-government owned enterprises – represents one of the most significant economic reforms that India can undertake, unlocking vital assets. Tardiness in addressing this objective detracts from the stated Atmanirbhar Bharat objective and widens the gap between the government’s announcements and achievements.